The Scoop

By Dalton Del Don

I’m not exactly going out on a limb saying I like Roy Halladay this season, and I’m guessing I also won’t be the only person to suggest a move from the AL to the NL will be beneficial. However, I’m here to argue he should be closer to the No. 1 fantasy starter than anything below it, and while I typically won’t draft a SP too early, his current ADP (32.26) seems extremely low, as I view him as a legitimate late first round option. Halladay’s fairly high workloads over the past four seasons are of some concern, but the improvement in his K rate over the past two years has turned him into an elite fantasy option. Halladay’s xFIP has ranked first and fourth over that time span, respectively, and few pitchers possess his ability to induce groundballs (50.2 GB% last year) with such a strong K rate. Everyone knows Halladay is good, of course, but the move to the National League really can’t be understated. Over the past two seasons, he put up remarkable numbers (leading all of baseball in K:BB ratio each year), and he did so while facing the second-highest opponents’ aggregate OPS in 2008 and third-highest in 2009. To put that in perspective, Tim Lincecum’s schedule was ranked as the 54th hardest last year. And if you’re of the opinion wins are predictable, well, the Phillies’ loaded lineup shouldn’t hurt matters. Going from a division that featured three teams that finished in the top-seven in runs scored last season to one with the Nationals, Mets and Braves (who all finished in bottom-half of MLB in scoring), how good could Halladay’s numbers end up looking this year? I hope I find out that answer with him on my fantasy team.

It sounds like it will take Carlos Beltran 12 weeks before he even starts baseball activities, so don’t expect to see him before June at the earliest. Stay away in fantasy leagues unless he comes at a real discount.

Pablo Sandoval truly is a pretty rare case. He sports a .333 career batting average despite being by far the freest swinger in all of baseball. In fact, he had the second-highest O-Swing% (percentage of pitches a batter swings at outside the strike zone) last year (second only to teammate Bengie Molina. As you can infer, the Giants really understand the merits of working the count) and would have “led” the category if he had enough at-bats during his rookie campaign in 2008. Moreover, “Kung Fu Panda” (seriously, how baked must have Barry Zito been when he was sitting at home watching that cartoon when he came up with the nickname?) also had the highest Z-Swing% (percentage of pitches a batter swings at inside the strike zone) last year as well. What does this all mean, exactly? His .356 career BABIP suggests he can get away with this, but his 717 at-bat sample is hardly enough to learn if that number is sustainable. Then again, there’s also plenty of room for him to grow as a hitter given that he’s just 23 years old. Swinging at essentially every pitch thrown at him last season, Sandoval’s .943 OPS ranked seventh-best in the NL, and he somehow posted a 35:28 K:BB ratio after the All-Star break, so he showed signs of improvement in plate discipline. He’s generally viewed as a poor defensive player, but his -4.1 UZR rating at third last year wasn’t exactly an abomination for someone learning a brand new position at the major league level. I’ve never seen a more athletic person who weighs 250 pounds, but it’s also nice to hear about his rigorous offseason workout regime. Of course, it’s usually best to ignore such stories, and he’s supposedly gained some weight back after travelling home to Venezuela, but Sandoval clearly understands the benefits of taking care of your body, which can’t be bad. Someday I hope to do the same thing. With improved hitters surrounding him in the lineup, Sandoval’s counting stats have nowhere to go but up as well. I’d take him over Mark Reynolds.

I don’t know about you, but this tweet from Matt Holliday made me lower him in my outfield rankings.

On the opposite spectrum of the young and upcoming corner infielders, I wouldn’t mind grabbing Troy Glaus late in drafts. At age 33 and coming off a season ruined by injuries, he shouldn’t be too costly in fantasy leagues, but it’s worth noting over the previous four years (from 2005-2008), he averaged 31 homers and 91 RBI while never accruing even 550 at-bats in a season, including getting just 385 ABs in 2007. Glaus isn’t going to help in batting average, but if he’s back to health in 2010, there might not be a cheaper source for power.

A “Story Highlight” from Peter King’s latest MMQB column: “If Dwight Freeney sits with an ankle injury, Saints’ chances of winning increase.” Folks, you can’t get this insight elsewhere.

Good defensive back breakdown by Football Outsiders. It reinstates the obvious – that Darrelle Revis was the best defensive player in the NFL in 2009. But it also shows just how much respect the rest of the league has for Nnamdi Asomugha.

Jeff Clement is someone I’ll be targeting, especially in 2-C or NL-only leagues. He’s been completely overmatched during his big league career (.237/.295/.360 with 66 strikeouts over 219 at-bats), but that’s an extremely small sample, and this is someone who has posted an .865 OPS over his minor league career (1,526 ABs) and will now be moving to the easier league after Pittsburgh traded for him. Clement was taken third overall in the 2005 draft out of USC, so the pedigree is there, and the Pirates figure to give him a legitimate opportunity after he was the centerpiece of a trade that saw the team ship both Ian Snell and Jack Wilson to Seattle. Like all prospects, Clement may or may not pan out, but there’s a real chance he acts as the Pirates’ first baseman this season, and since he’ll be catcher eligible in fantasy leagues, he could prove to be a steal while playing everyday.

For those with Shin-Soo Choo in keeper leagues, you can breathe a big sigh of relief.

First the negatives: Juan Pierre isn’t a good real life asset, who played way out of his head during Manny Ramirez’s 50-game suspension last season and has hit one homer combined over the past three seasons. Still, there’s also plenty to like about his fantasy value in 2010. He’s been traded to the White Sox, where manager Ozzie Guillen will no doubt overrate Pierre’s silly attributes like speed and grittiness, which should lead to an everyday job, probably as the leadoff hitter. While he may have to adjust to playing in the American League for the first time in his career, Pierre moves to a much more favorable hitter’s park, and this is someone who averaged 55 steals over a seven-year span (2001-2007) before seeing decreased playing time in L.A. over the past two seasons (and even then, he swiped a whopping 70 bags despite never receiving more than 380 at-bats in either year). Incredibly durable, Pierre also sports a 337:340 K:BB ratio throughout his career, so he’s very likely to help in BA as well. I’m a big fan of Jacoby Ellsbury (20.34 ADP), but it makes a whole lot of sense to draft Pierre 17 rounds later (251 ADP).

The best answer to an interview I’ve seen since Mike Tyson was prominent. Since I’ve seen this, I’ve started to use this specific answer as a response to basically all things in life.

The first of many to come.

I’m staying far away from Ryan Franklin at draft tables this year. He enters 2010 as the Cardinals’ closer, but there’s little reason to respect his ERA (1.92) from last season. This is a pitcher with unimpressive stuff who posted a 17:17 K:BB ratio (and a 1.70 WHIP) after the All-Star break last season, and while he typically keeps the ball on the ground, last year’s 85.7 LOB% and ridiculously lucky 3.7 HR/F% simply aren’t repeatable. Jason Motte, meanwhile, posted an 8.58 K/9 last year and suffered poor luck with a HR/F% of 16.6. He’s been criticized in the past for being essentially a one-pitch pitcher, but his slider was actually effective last season, and although his fastball wasn’t, the average velocity was 95.9 mph, and let’s not forget he posted an 11.9 K/9 over 164.2 minor league innings while also fanning 27 batters over 23.1 innings after the All-Star break for St. Louis last season. With Chris Perez now in Cleveland, there are few alternatives in the Cards’ bullpen. Forget the discrepancy in ADPs, I’d draft Motte ahead of Franklin this year.

As for this installment of my YouTube songs, I’m throwing a curveball right out of the gate: a Bjork song with a music video directed by the ridiculously talented Michel Gondry:


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

11 responses to “The Scoop”

  1. i am Jack's fantasy baseball team Avatar
    i am Jack’s fantasy baseball team

    Great stuff. Holliday post made me laugh. Agree about Motte. Bryce Harper reminds me of Kelly Leak.

  2. Eddie Avatar
    Eddie

    It was one thing for Holliday to tweet the Creed-love, but the hyper-sensitive tweets after made it even worse.

    “I probably hate some of your stuff. Pretty sure that’s why there is whole bunch of different kinds of music. Note to self no more musictweet”

    “Fuh-get it, Matt. It’s Twitter.”

  3. Corey Avatar
    Corey

    Re. Holliday

    I celebrate his entire catalog.

  4. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    I agree – Holliday’s defensive antics afterward made it all even better.

  5. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    And if only we knew his “entire catalog.”

  6. jackjester Avatar
    jackjester

    Of course Holiday is a card carrying member of the Creed fan club – heard it every time he came to bat at Coors Field – felt like someone was pissing in my ears.

    Sure you’ve seen this, but enjoy if not. Watch it all – BALLS funny…

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tqQB2J7NXRI

  7. Poincare Avatar
    Poincare

    DDD,

    I agree with you regarding Halladay, but I don’t think his current ADP is a reliable and accurate indicator of where he will really go in most drafts this season. I’d be very surprised if he’s still available in the 3rd round in my 13-team redraft league; if he is I’ll take him there without thinking twice. I just can’t see myself taking him with my 2nd round pick no matter where I end up picking, and I expect him to be gone sometime that round.

    I fully expect his strikeouts to go up facing the opposing pitcher three times a game, which leads me to my first question. Do you have any idea what Halladay did between 2007 and 2008 that caused the substantial jump in his strikeouts? I clearly remember that I was actually a little down on Halladay going into 2008 because of his unimpressive strikeout rate. So he doesn’t end up on any of my teams that season as he strikes out over 200. Ahh, fantasy…

    If they give odds for stuff like this I think Halladay should be the favorite over Lincecum to win the 2010 NL Cy Young. The biggest reason being that if they have comparable seasons you know the writers will figure out some way to lean towards Halladay since Lincecum has already won it the past two seasons. This potential scenario so clearly reminds me of Randy Johnson and Curt Schilling in 2002. I remember that Cy Young Race vividly.

    Their stats were almost identical going into September. Schilling was 21-5 with a 2.79 ERA and 275 K’s in 221 IP; Johnson was 19-5 with a 2.63 ERA and 285 K’s in 219 IP. They were clearly the two best pitchers in the league. There was no doubt in my mind, however, that at that point in the season Schilling was the odds-on favorite to win the Cy Young–partly because he was clearly the sentimental favorite among the writers because he had yet to win the award and partly because Johnson had won it the last two seasons. I was 100% convinced that even if they had finished the season with the same W-L record and Johnson had finished the season with a lower ERA and more K’s that the writers would still figure out some way to give Schilling the award. As it turned out, Schilling went 2-2 with a 5.87 ERA in September while Johnson finished 5-0 with a 0.66 ERA (not a misprint). When all was said and done Johnson had outpitched Schilling in every important way: W-L record, K’s, ERA was almost a full run lower at the end of the season (2.32 to 3.23),…Schilling did have a better WHIP than Johnson that season, but I doubt the writers have ever looked at that category when deciding their Cy Young votes. Because of Johnson’s finish and their final numbers there was no way that Schilling could win the award over Johnson now without the writers looking biased if not outright incompetent. Johnson ended up winning unanimously, but I’m still convinced Schilling would have won the award if his final numbers had been closer to Johnson’s.

    Carlos Beltran is one of my favorite players. I’m getting concerned that these nagging injuries in his 30’s could dampen his coming seasons to the point where he won’t make the cut for the Hall of Fame. I think that would be a real shame; he has been one of the very best players in the game for a decade, but his career totals could very well end up a little underwhelming.

    I love Pablo Sandoval. He is the one hitter in the Giants line-up who’s always worth watching, and on an offense like the Giants’ he really sticks out (as I’m sure you know, much better than I do). His ADP on Mock Draft Central is 42. I don’t see any way in hell he’ll last until pick #42 in my league. I’d rather have him on my team than Jimmy Rollins. My analytical side has such a hard time accepting him as a true .330 hitter, but the baseball fan in me is hoping that he is one.

    Here’s one time I’m going to follow my instincts and flat out disagree with you DDD. I’m telling you, the best Troy Glaus will do this season is a .235 BA with about 20 home runs–and I actually think that is optimistic. Your argument makes all the sense in the world, but I’m pretty sure I’ve watched Glaus play more than you have since his early days with the Angels. I’ve always like Glaus as a player, but I don’t think he’ll stay any healthier playing 1B instead 3B, and taking into consideration his age, injury history, and size, I don’t think he’ll ever be a good major league player again. Above replacement level maybe, but not good.

    Regarding Ryan Franklin, have you thought about the conundrum his owners are faced with in keeper leagues? I’m almost sure he went for peanuts, if he was drafted at all, in almost every league last season. Think of all the guys out there who own the Cardinals’ closer at a single digit salary, most likely under $5. I agree with you that there is no way he will be on any my teams this season, but it would be hard not to keep him for less than $5 in any format.

    I know you’re a Giants fan. What’s the latest you’ve heard on Angel Villalona? Is there any feasible chance he plays in the minors this season and stays on track to make his major league debut in a couple of years?

  8. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    jackjester – I had not seen that actually. Funny stuff. I thought it really was them for like the first half of the video.

  9. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Poincare – I agree – that ADP for Halladay is worthless b/c it won’t be a reflection of any competitive league you or I will be in. Your guess is as good as mine regarding his spiked K rate over the past two years. His fastball velocity has remained relatively steady, although he has started to throw his cutter a lot more over those past two years. I agree about Halladay for Cy Young – b/c he’s also the favorite to have more wins than Lincecum.

    Crazy how good Randy Johnson used to be.

    You could very well be right about Glaus. At least he shouldn’t cost too much in fantasy leagues to find out. But I do admit, his BA may not make him worth the trouble, even if the power returns.

    I’d keep Franklin for $5 or less, but I’d also be trying to trade him furiously.

    Last I heard about Villalona is that he paid off the victim’s family, who then refused to cooperate with authorities, and it sounded like he’d eventually get off. But the SF organization will almost certainly want nothing to do with him regardless, b/c it’s clear (at least on most accounts) that he truly did commit murder.

  10. A2K Avatar
    A2K

    TripD
    I agree with you that Halladay is turning out to be quite the value in early mocks. I seriously doubt that he will win the NL CY Young. The other Lincecum guy is flatout better and pitches in a better park.
    I don’t believe in Choo. That Cleveland lineup is anemic until Santana and Laporta get there. Further, I’m not sure if Grady Sizemore has taken any naked or scantily clad pics of himself this year.
    Lastly, I’m in a shallow keeper league. Can only keep 2.
    Al Rod
    Troy Tu
    Just an Upton
    First instinct was Rab, and Justin.
    Then I said to myself, well…

  11. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    A2K – Won’t find a bigger Timmy fan than me, but I’d take even odds on Halladay vs. him to win this year’s Cy.

    I expect a nice bounce back year from Sizemore. And Sizemore’s pics got nothing on Oden’s.

    ARod is a no-brainer, obviously, and then Tulo vs. Upton is tough. Very tough. I hate doing this, but this is so close, I recommend going with your gut. Tulo typically goes a bit earlier in drafts, but that shouldn’t matter too much. Ugh. I say go with your first instinct and Upton, especially since it’s a keeper league and this guy could be a universal top-five pick in 2011.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *