The Scoop

By Dalton Del Don

I expect John Smoltz to return to the mound within three weeks and be a top-five closer over the course of the season. Considering his age and balky shoulder, he’s certainly not without risk, but his stuff was about as good as ever before going on the DL. He knows how his arm responds best, so I trust his decision to move to the pen will result in better health, even if it comes down to him pitching through some soreness. If you’re looking for saves, might as well see how worried his owner is by making an offer.

Ted Lilly is officially back. A terrible start has left his ERA still sitting at 5.33, but his WHIP is 1.28, and his 8.8 K/9 IP mark is 12th best in major league baseball. Over his last four starts, he has a sparkling 32:6 K:BB ratio. His velocity has returned, and the Cubs field a terrific offense with a solid back-end to the bullpen. Lilly has never been the most durable pitcher, but he needs to be treated like a top-25 starter right now.

Ian Snell, conversely, is someone to worry about. Snell’s inability to come up with a third pitch has really hindered his development, and all those sliders are taking a toll on his arm. He’s still young enough to turn it around, but after last year’s second half (4.83 ERA, 1.53 WHIP), this season’s 5.05 ERA is disconcerting. The sinking K rate and rising BB rate are particularly discouraging.

For a game that’s played on the same exact dimensions everywhere, it’s pretty crazy just how important homecourt advantage is in NBA basketball.

Nick Johnson’s trip to the disabled list was about as surprising as someone from ESPN using the phrase “by the way.” Cal Ripken Jr. can now rest easy. Johnson was playing much better than his .220 average indicated too. The worst part is the nature of the injury, as there’s no guarantee his wrist won’t be a major problem even when he’s able to return to the field.

Song of the week: “Time to Pretend” by MGMT.

Curtis Granderson is hitless during four at-bats against left-handers this season, one year after batting .160/.225/.269 versus southpaws in 2007. He’s the rare superstar who can be benched at times in daily formats. Staying with the Tigers, Justin Verlander has been one of the five most disappointing players in baseball so far. His 6.05 ERA is accompanied by a .291 BABIP, which is right in line with his career mark, so that can’t be blamed. His .59 strand rate is sure to improve, but the fact his walks are up and his Ks are so down isn’t a great sign at all. After nine starts, his season-high for strikeouts in a game is six. Dating back to last year, he’s now served up 13 homers over his past 12 starts, which isn’t going to cut it. He’s also hit seven batters this season, which is worst in the league. I wouldn’t necessarily be trying to sell Verlander, but I also wouldn’t be aggressively trying to buy-low either.

Fun stats: Ryan Theriot’s seven caught stealings are by far the most in baseball. David Ortiz has grounded into the most double plays (10) in the league. Albert Pujols has been intentionally walked 12 times, which is almost twice the amount of anyone else. Bengie Molina has been the toughest player to strike out this year, fanning just once every 26 at-bats. Dustin Pedroia and Ryan Zimmerman have recorded the most outs in all of baseball.

Brett Myers’ loss in velocity can help explain his league-leading 15 home runs allowed, but that he’s also maintained an 8.1 K/9 IP mark is a little strange. Maybe the jumping back-and-forth between the rotation, bullpen and then rotation again wasn’t such a great idea after all. There’s pretty good reason for concern here.

Daniel Cabrera’s 3.58 ERA and 1.23 WHIP are great, and so is the fact he’s walked just one batter over the past two starts (16 innings). His newfound ability to induce a bunch of groundballs is another encouraging sign. Still, for someone with his stuff, Cabrera’s K rate (5.5 K/9 IP) is beyond disappointing, and his .240 BABIP suggests he’s been quite lucky. There’s no doubt he’s improving as a pitcher, but as much as I want to believe he’s truly turned the corner, it’s best to remain skeptical.

Chris Duncan is batting just .258 with three homers on the year, but he can be quite useful in daily formats. Injuries curtailed what was looking like a big season last year, and he’s really improved his walk rate in 2008, which could lead to him consistently hitting high in St. Louis’ order. He’s unusable versus left-handers, but Duncan has hit 20 homers in 295 career at-bats against righties, so he’s a fine option against them. However, hopefully he limits his smoking to just photo day and not game days.


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

14 responses to “The Scoop”

  1. Tyler Durden Avatar
    Tyler Durden

    Funny, I said the same thing about Verlander is trade talks today. An owner wanted to make a larger deal and I commented all I saw on his end was adding Verlander, however I was not even sure I wanted to take the risk.

    A month-and-a-half ago, who would have thought this would be the common thought about him?

    I think I diagree about Smoltz.

    Nick Johnson. Ugh.

  2. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Ya, I was pretty high on Verlander entering the year. And again, it’s def. possible he does turn it around. Just that the peripherals are as discouraging as his ERA.

  3. Brett Avatar

    DDD,

    I’m equally worried about Snell. He doesn’t seem right.

    I do seem skeptical about Cabrera as well. I don’t trust him at all.

  4. Donald Trump Avatar
    Donald Trump

    This NBA home court thing is getting out of control at this point. It unsettles me a little. Thank God we don’t have this problem in baseball.

    Edwin Jackson seems as interesting (if you are as desperate for SP in a deep league as I am) as Dcab.

    Brett Myers is dropable. I am thinking Shefield is too.

  5. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Edwin Jackson is a good comp to DCab – former prospect showing signs of developing late. I’m also a little skeptical about him tho.

  6. Dreamweapon Avatar
    Dreamweapon

    I’m actually going to take the other path here and continue to promote D-Cab for this season. Don’t get me wrong, in seasons past I have been in the vanguard of the world’s foremost D-Cab haters and continually ridiculed his owner(s) in my various leagues. But here’s the thing: the absurd BB rate was, by far, his biggest drawback, and he seems to have addressed it. He’s just racked up too many quality starts this year, and the skyrocketing GB rate and bonanza of double plays that attend it, means the horrific risk that went with starting him has essentially dissipated. I’m just not worried about the Ks, his arm is intact and that is something he can rediscover easily enough when he needs to. The biggest thing was cutting down baserunners, and getting the ball over the plate, if you have the proper movement on it, can get that done when it means a rash of weak squibbers to your middle infielders. It seems that his pitching coach has convinced him to stop trying to locate corners and just concentrate on throwing the ball in the proximity of the plate and letting his stuff take care of the rest. He’s throwing something like 95% fastballs, and still the league isn’t beating on him like they used to. This means he’s at least safe, he won’t kill you. I will take a probable 7 IP with 9 baserunners and 5 Ks over a possible 5 IP with a like number of baserunners and 10 Ks any day of the week. If he wants to try emulating Brandon Webb instead of Big Ugly, I say great. Assuming he continues to hold it together, he’ll be free to start to incorporate more of his secondary pitches as the season progresses, and probable start racking up more Ks in the process.

    Or, he could revert to being a headcase and completely fall apart, it IS D-Cab. But these first six weeks have laid the foundation for a year I had thought was far beyond his abilities at this point. Gotta learn to walk before you can run.

  7. Dreamweapon Avatar
    Dreamweapon

    Also, Verlander may suck but he’s completely untradeable at this point. In the only league where I have him, someone offered me, haha, Austin Kearns and Scott Baker for him. I have like six OF better than Kearns and basically view Baker as back-of-the-rotation FA spot-start fodder. I would rather take a guaranteed last place and just go down with the ship than take an absurd deal like that, out of principle.

    Just hang on and hope his fortunes rise and the weather warms up a bit. As a midwesterner, I can tell you it has been an extremely cold Spring so far. Maybe it’s had an effect. I don’t see the point in dealing him for pennies on the dollar. Maybe it’s a “return”, sure, but they’re still pennies. Hold the line, Verlander owners, unless you get a significant chip.

  8. Donald Trump Avatar
    Donald Trump

    “I would rather take a guaranteed last place and just go down with the ship than take an absurd deal like that, out of principle.”
    I agree, at least concerning verlander. I don’t have much faith in him, but I am still trying to steal him in my leagues.

  9. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Chris Liss brought up a similar theory Dreamweapon, essentially saying DCab is recording fewer strike outs b/c he’s dialed it down in order to improve control, and once he starts mastering that better, the Ks will go back up again. It’s an interesting concept like your own assessment, and I’m willing to not totally disregard it. Don’t get me wrong, I picked him up in a deep league a few weeks back and still hold hope. There are def. encouraging signs.

  10. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    And that’s a preposterous offer for Verlander. Obscene.

  11. Thebestfantasyplayer Avatar
    Thebestfantasyplayer

    The great one is here:

    D Cabrera sucks and will fall apart as the season goes along.

    Saying John Smoltz is going to be a good closer isnt really groundbreaking…im sure he will do well as long as he stays healthy

    Verlander?? hes been throwing 92-93 all year long and last year he was throwing 97-99 all year…something tells me something is wrong….this nonsense that the Tigers want him to throw 92-93 to learn how to “pitch” and conserve his arm for the second halves of the season is completely ridiculous…why would Leyland tell Verlander to not throw as hard..ive never heard such crap…hes obviously hurting a little…his ball isnt moving as much…his fastball isnt as hard…and hes lost confidence…and even when he pitches well the Tigers bullpen is terrible…i traded verlander for Granderson str8 up 10 days ago…trade him to a owner who thinks he will turn it around

    Adam Dunn is about to get hot

    Lance Berkman is about to cool off

    Roy Oswalt is about to turn it around and have a 10-2 stretch…add him if you can

    Johan Santana will have an ERA under 2.20 in the second half..add him if any owner is a little down on him

    Nick Markakis is a very strong second half player…add him if you can considering he has struggled so far this season

    Ryan Howard had a monster second half last season…dont dump him now

    Cliff Lee will not end up with more then 15 wins

    Brandon Webb will not win 20 even though he has 9 wins already

    These are just some tidbits from thebestfantasyplayer

  12. The Jewru Avatar
    The Jewru

    The good lord has blessed me. I was able to pawn off Verlander last night to my friend who was sauced up on Sangria. Verlander, Uggla and Nathan for Sabathia, Kinsler and Fuentes. Thank You Jesus. Thank You Jesus.

    Best fantasy player nice post actually but I have to disagree with the Webb thing. I think Webb wins 20 easy and has taken his place as the best pitcher in the league.

  13. randy Avatar
    randy

    2 thoughts in lifetime league a. gonzalez and pat burrell for prince fielder and a. dunn or a. gonzalez and b. abreau for c. pena and n. markakis———-what should i do————best fantasy player what do you think also——-thanks

  14. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Tough call, and I don’t feel all that strongly one way or the other, but I like the Fielder/Dunn deal slightly more. I love Markakis in a lifetime league, and getting rid of the declining Abreu in that format is good too, but Pena is a little worrisome with his lack of track record and all those Ks (although I’m still pretty confident a bunch of HRs are on the way). Still, with the other deal you’d be selling high with Burrell and buying low with Dunn, while also upgrading at 1B.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *