The Scoop

By Dalton Del Don – Senior Writer

There isn’t anyone getting consistently overdrafted more than Javier Vazquez. I’ve always liked Vazquez’s stuff, dating back to his days as an Expo. However, the fact remains 2007 was the first season he finished with an ERA under 4.42 in four years. He’s always a help in WHIP, and the strikeouts are legit, but Vazquez is an extreme flyball pitcher who plays in one of the most homer-friendly ballparks in baseball. Last year, his groundball/flyball ratio actually decreased from the season before, when he posted a 4.84 ERA. The glaring difference? His strand rate jumped from .640 in 2006 to .720 last season. I wouldn’t count on it happening again.

I view Jeff Francis similarly, as prospective fantasy owners are focusing way too much on last year’s 17 wins and too little on the underlying peripherals when overdrafting the lefthander. Coors Field is still a very undesirable place to pitch, and 4.22 ERAs are rarely accompanied by 1.38 WHIPs. Expect him to finish this year with something resembling his second half numbers from 2006. He’s not a top-60 fantasy starter in my eyes.

I’d like to apologize to Rocco Baldelli, my personal whipping boy ever since he killed numerous fantasy teams of mine over the past couple of years. There’s a joke somewhere to be made regarding the fact his career is over due to “fatigue,” but I’ve made enough at his expense. The guy’s life may be in jeopardy for crying out loud. Farewell, Rocco Baldelli.

I really don’t understand why catchers aren’t more heavily targeted. There is a clear-cut top-4, and then a precipitous drop off. If you are playing in a 2-C league, there are some pretty awful options if you wait too long, whereas even the 80th outfielder can produce decent enough stats. This is the one clear position that needs to be addressed early based on scarcity.

I always preach not to draft based on last year’s stats, but if anyone’s 2006 is under the radar, it’s Mark Ellis’. Here’s a second baseman who basically finished with a line of .275-20-10-80-80 while missing more than 10 games. I doubt he’ll do it again, but as one of the game’s best defensive players, he’s pretty valuable to the A’s. Aaron Hill also had a very effective and under the radar season last year.

Conor Jackson is one of my favorite mid-to-late round targets. Slated to bat third in the Diamondbacks’ lineup, Jackson has a very favorable home park and quietly hit .308/.371/.555 after the All-Star break last season. He doesn’t have light-tower power, but eight homers over his final 130 at-bats in 2006 suggest it’s developing. His 50:53 K:BB ratio last season also portends a future .310-.320 type hitter.

Shane Victorino has to be one of the first 25-30 outfielders taken in drafts. While most speedsters contribute very little in the power department, Victorino can chip in 15 bombs, and his remarkable 90 percent success rate (37-for-41) on the basepaths last year means plenty more running should be in his future. The only real difference I can find between Carl Crawford and him is about 25 points in batting average.

If Michael Cuddyer finds himself batting between Joe Mauer, Justin Morneau and Delmon Young, he’s going to end up as a serious bargain in fantasy leagues. Part of last year’s drop in slugging can be blamed on injury, and yet he still finished with respectable numbers despite missing 20 games. He’s also 11-for-11 on stolen base attempts over the last two seasons, so he could probably swipe 15 bags if he wanted to.

Billy Butler is an excellent end-game pick, especially those who play in Yahoo leagues, as he’s first base eligible. Butler’s power is still developing, and he certainly needs to improve against right-handed pitching, but he more than held his own as a 21-year-old in the majors last season and could really break out in 2008. He’s a legitimate .300 hitter and eventually all of those doubles are going to turn into homers.

I’ve developed an unhealthy man-crush on Lastings Milledge. It’s simply impossible for me to draft this guy too high. In fact, I recently picked him in the 12th round of one league. I guess I have a soft spot for head cases, but this is a pretty unique talent with both legitimate power and speed. One should largely ignore spring stats, but I’ve stupidly been fixated by his line of .389/.476/.583 with five steals in 36 meaningless at-bats.


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

14 responses to “The Scoop”

  1. Donald Trump Avatar
    Donald Trump

    Seriously, this has got the be the best baseball blog out there.

  2. Tyler Durden Avatar
    Tyler Durden

    I will second that emotion.

  3. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Thanks….Spread the word!!

  4. Brett Avatar

    Nice job DDD.. quality post.

    Love Butler this year.. his AVG could hover around .310 I think.

    Jackson is a huge breakout guy and Victorino is being underrated sicne he missed the last 6 weeks of 2007. He looks like he could steal 50 given a full healthy season.

  5. Lister Avatar
    Lister

    Like my gut’s, PECOTA’s projections are a lot more favorable for Vazquez than you are. I had him around 15 on my SP rankings; PECOTA has him at 11, in any case both rankings position Javy well ahead of the consistently over-drafted West Coast youth triumvirate of King Felix, Tim Lincecum, and Matt Cain. Vazquez racks up the strikeouts and takes the ball every 5th day year in and year out. Those two facts alone are extremely valuable in my book, and the latter especially in such a deep league.

    http://www.baseball-reference.com/v/vazquja01.shtml

    Time will tell. But I’m pretty pleased w/ taking him after the 10th round.

  6. Walt Weiss Avatar
    Walt Weiss

    Yo, I’m concurring on your analysis of Mark Ellis, but what do you think about his homeboy Daric Barton?

  7. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    I like Barton – he’s a very good hitter. Not a ton of power right now, but he’ll be on base at a high clip and should rack up runs/RBI with a solid BA.

  8. Keith Avatar
    Keith

    In an OBP league, Barton should be solid. He showed better than expected power during his short stint in the bigs last year, and has hit a couple of bombs so far in the spring, but I think it’s best to temper expectations in the power department for him. He should hit in the top of the order though (possibly even #3 eventually), and the A’s offense isn’t going to be as bad as people think, so I agree with Dalton that runs/RBI’s could be respectable. I’m not convinced about Conor’s power (most projections call for about 15 HR’s…ouch), but I really could use a 1st baseman, so am thinking about going after him as a low-cost high-upside guy. On that note…

    I’m torn on a trade offer I just received in my dynasty league. We use OBP instead of AVG, and have total bases as a 6th category. I’ve been trying to get Swisher to play 1B, and I got this offer:

    Carlos Beltran
    Nick Swisher
    Phil Hughes

    for:

    Corey Hart
    Curtis Granderson

    Total Bases is a huge plus for Granderson, and I’m kind of worried about Hart’s OBP since he doesn’t walk much at all. Swisher and Beltran should post good OBP’s, but I’m very worried about Beltran’s health, and don’t think it’ll be long before Granderson is worth as much (maybe this year if he can hit lefties?). Since I could really use a 1B, and I think Swisher is going to hit 30+ HR’s, I’m pretty tempted, especially since Hughes’ velocity seems to be coming back, and I think he’d fit in well in my rotation with Felix, Liriano and Smoltz. I just would have a very hard time giving up Hart and Granderson in a dynasty league. Any thoughts?

  9. Keith Avatar
    Keith

    I just noticed you actually already ranked Granderson one spot ahead of Beltran; interesting. I could still see a 40/20 year from Beltran with pretty sick run/RBI totals. I think the big question is will Grandy ever learn to hit lefties. If he stays at the top of that lineup against lefties and righties, he should lead the league in runs scored.

  10. Tyler Durden Avatar
    Tyler Durden

    4 days sans post. Any chance we could get The Scoop every other day at least? It would be nice.

    Mind you, that is a compliment.

  11. Steve Avatar
    Steve

    Does your rule about not drafting based on last year’s stats apply mainly to pitchers and vets? Because if not, my high picks yesterday of Hanley, Markakis, BJ Ups, A-Gonz and Corey Hart have me feeling even dumber than usual….

  12. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Keith – First off, I think projecting C. Jackson for 15 homers is foolish, unless they foresee an injury. Like I said, the guy hit 8 HRs over his last 130 ABs last year, plays in a terrific hitter’s park and is 25 years old – I think anyone reasonable would expect improvement. He hit 15 HRs in 415 ABs last year.

    What a tough call for your trade offer. On one hand Granderson is worthless against lefties. On the other, Beltran is still dealing with leg issues and is only getting older. But I also like Swisher and Hughes to have very solid seasons. I guess my best advice would be this: if it’s a deep league where Swisher/Hughes would be replacing scrubs, then I’d do it. If it’s a shallow league where there are solid replacements available on the waiver wire and studs matter most, then I wouldn’t. Hope that makes sense. Either way, it’s a very tough/close call. You should go with your gut.

  13. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Tyler Durden – I’ll probably post some rankings early this week, but I’ll also try to bust out some legit “Scoops” more frequently with the season fast approaching.

  14. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Steve – I guess my answer is it depends. But yes, for the most part, it probably does apply to vets and seasons that don’t really apply to the rest of someone’s career. Those 5 players you mentioned are all guys I’m very high on entering this year, so I personally wouldn’t apply that theory and would be more than happy to acquire them.

    Those guys are young and showed signs of improvement in secondary skills as well, meaning big campaigns should follow. The main idea I meant by that is that sometimes people get lucky for a season (Posada’s BABIP in 2007), and that baseball is a very tough game, so don’t expect players to repeat great performances necessarily and also don’t disregard poor performances from the year before. Drafting “last year’s scrubs” can often be fruitful.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *