The Scoop

By Dalton Del Don – Senior Writer

I’m not sure what’s more surprising, that some of the media think the recent claim that Derek Jeter is a poor fielding shortstop is untrue, or that these people find this theory new. Jeter has frequently finished worst in Major League Baseball in putouts from the position and has long been overrated thanks to timely big plays in October. Now that Carlos Guillen is off the position, Jeter might very well be the worst fielding shortstop in all of baseball.

If one could buy stock in a baseball team, I’d be all over the Tampa Bay Rays right now. The price would have to be seemingly low playing in that division, and I’m not sure I’ve ever seen a franchise loaded with this much pitching talent. Scott Kazmir and James Shields are elite talents right now. Matt Garza isn’t far away, and David Price, Jacob McGee and Wade Davis are three of the top-10 pitching prospects in baseball. It doesn’t end there, as Jeremy Hellickson and even Jeff Niemann have legitimate upside down the road as well. The organization has some pretty decent young hitters too, Rocco Baldelii notwithstanding.

In quite possibly the worst analysis I’ve ever read, The Dallas Morning News’ Tim McMahon recently predicted Julius Jones will rush for 1,700 yards next season because he has averaged 155 rushing yards at Seattle’s Qwest Field during, get this, two career games. He does realize Jones will be playing for the Seahawks and not against them, right?

Looking over the odds to win the World Series is always entertaining this time of year. Since going with the favorites is never fun (or fruitful), let’s take a look at some of the longer shots who have a decent chance at going deep this season. I have no clue why the Cardinals (40/1) are favored more than the Reds (50/1), who at least have some upside in young arms. Then again, Vegas probably weighted the Dusty Baker factor heavily. I wouldn’t mind throwing a couple bones on the Brewers (30/1), Braves (30/1) and/or the Dodgers (25/1).

If J.P. Riccardi could have persuaded the gullible Brian Sabean into the Alex Rios for Tim Lincecum (or Matt Cain) deal that was floated around during the offseason, I would have picked Toronto to win the AL East this season. This team has one of the best starting rotations in all of baseball even without the deal. Too bad that still leaves them as only the third best squad in its own division.

I had no idea John Henderson and I had so much in common. This is the same exact way I prepare for every RotoScoop article.

Chad Billingsley might very well win a Cy Young award someday, but for this year, I think he’s being drafted too highly. The stuff and the strikeout rate portend big things to come, but last year’s 3.92 BB/9 IP suggests growing pains are likely in store for 2008. He’s going to be a negative in WHIP, and that’s going to reflect in his ERA in the short-term as well.

Johnny Cueto is one of my favorite end-game picks and has to be drafted in all but the shallowest of leagues. The debate whether Homer Bailey or Cueto will be the better long-term bet is far from decided, but short-term, Cueto is more prepared to contribute at the big league level. Of course, Dusty Baker has to agree, something pretty unlikely. Still, it’s better to go with Cueto’s upside than a boring veteran guaranteed playing time when you reach the later parts of your draft.

Anyone looking for a deep sleeper saves candidate should consider Taylor Tankersley. Most pundits consider Matt Lindstrom the likely replacement behind incumbent Kevin Gregg (who will probably be moved at the deadline), and there’s nothing wrong with that, but Tankersley was the early favorite to close last season and was once the franchise’s first round draft pick. The fact he’s a lefty probably hurts his chances, but his numbers after the break last year (1.48 ERA, 12.3 K/9 IP) suggest he’ll be a valuable middle reliever at worst.


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

20 responses to “The Scoop”

  1. Davidian Avatar
    Davidian

    D,

    Vegas called and said set the line at 15/1 I win the Stevenson league with no preperation as usual, your thoughts on that? Heard you’re only going off at 6/5 this year…

  2. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Sounds about right. Anytime I’m set at even or worse is a great bet. What are Dusty’s odds?

  3. Steve Nolan Avatar
    Steve Nolan

    Worst defensive SS in baseball is a battle between Jeter and Hanley Ramirez this season.

    I jumped all over the Rays bandwagon last season. I’m from Boston and I think I might like the Rays just as much as I like the Sox, that’s how excited I am. And I’m not ready to write off Edwin Jackson or Andy Sonnanstine just yet.

  4. Donald Trump Avatar
    Donald Trump

    What do you think about David Price as a late round flier? I saw him pitch saturday, and he is nasty.

    Dreamweapon: your I Have A Dream speech worked its magic. I drafted Weeks at $14 in my draft yesterday. You better be right about him. I paired him with BJ upton, Alex gordon, Atkins, furcal, mcann, sizemore, hamilton, shef, beckett, shields, bonderman, as my stars. And yes, D Price for $1.

  5. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Steve – Good call with Hanley. He’s right up there with Jeter as far as poor fielding SS goes.

  6. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Donald – If it’s a real deep league, then Price is worth a late round flier. He’s going to be a stud. It’s just that I don’t see him as much more than a September call up for this season. But he could impress right away and he is from college not HS so maybe he’s readiness will be sped up.

    Looks like a very good squad there to me.

  7. Lister Avatar
    Lister

    Why are you so high on Cueto?

    And there is every single reason to think that, long term, Bailey will be the significantly better arm from where I stand.

  8. Dreamweapon Avatar
    Dreamweapon

    $14 for a guy with Weeks’ skills seems like highway robbery to me. He need only get something like 350 ABs to return that value, I would guess, so you could come out light years ahead in the bargain. Certainly worth the risk.

    I love David Price, I have him on my team’s farm system from last season–all the teams in my dynasty league can draft two “minor league” players, which was defined by the rule not as actual minor leaguers, but as batters with 130 ABs or less, or pitchers with 50 IP or less…..everyone had always just followed BA’s list or whatever, and the best prospects tended to be taken early in the draft. I needed immediate help with my team last year and wanted to use all my early picks on regulars, so I decided to draft college players, hoping there would be no fallout. Took Price in the next to last round, Matt Wieters last overall. Worked out great, I think. I’m planning on doing the same thing again this year with Pedro Alvarez and either Brian Matusz or Aaron Crow, although there is a prep SS (Beckham out of Griffin, Ga) that I am increasingly focusing on like a laser beam for that last pick, he has Barry Larkin written all over him.

    Anyway, that was long and boring, I’m sure, but suffice it to say, Price is great. Maybe not this year, but soon.

  9. Brett Avatar

    Cueto! Stolen from under me! I think he’s a better bet than Bailey… You’ve got to live in th present and not the past or future. Cueto is pitching better right now.

  10. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Lister – Bailey’s stuff may be a little better, and Cueto’s build is worrisome, but command is the most important aspect in pitching, and right now, Cueto is much better at that. Like I said, long-term, I’d still go Bailey. But it’s not a slam dunk.

  11. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Dreamweapon – Pretty amazing foresight there with Price. That’s going to pay off big time. Same goes for Wieters, who is going to be a monster and obviously plays the scarcest position in the game.

  12. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Brett – Cueto!!

  13. Lister Avatar
    Lister

    Bailey’s stuff is more than a little better, no? Maybe 3MPH on the heater, though they’re reportedly fairly even. But Cueto can’t match that yellowhammer curve, can he?

    I’ve seen Bailey throw; never Cueto. So I’m bullshitting, but I may still be right.

  14. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Like I said. Command is huge. Daniel Cabrera might have the best stuff in all of baseball. But yes, Cueto can’t match Bailey’s, especially his curve.

  15. Steve Nolan Avatar
    Steve Nolan

    Oh, Daniel Cabrera. I was sucked in to the hype after I saw him pitch 6 perfect innings against the D-Backs in ’04…even though he was outdueled by Casey Fossum!

    http://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/boxscore;_ylt=AuCsaQ.Tp421M3ufy607OiyFCLcF?gid=240610101

    I know, I can’t believe it either.

  16. Lister Avatar
    Lister

    Know who has good stuff?

    Victor Zambrano.

  17. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Remember when the Red Sox refused to part with Fossum? They wouldn’t even trade him for Bartolo Colon (who was pretty good then, coming off a Cy Young).

    I still think Cabrera could turn it around one of these years, but then again, I thought it’d already happen by now and even Leo Mazzone couldn’t do it.

  18. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Does Victor Zambrano have better stuff than Scott Kazmir?

  19. Rick Peterson Avatar
    Rick Peterson

    Plllease just give me 10 minutes and I can fix him. Just 10 minutes I swear!!

  20. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Good luck, Rick!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *