Take Your Pick

Often you will find two players who are being drafted typically right around the same area and have similar price tags in auctions. Maybe both will bring back close to equal value in returns. Or, the decision could make or break your season. Leave your choice and thoughts on the matter in the comments section.

Garrett Atkins or Ryan Zimmerman?


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

5 responses to “Take Your Pick”

  1. Chris Avatar
    Chris

    Atkins Atkins Atkins!

  2. Brett Avatar

    Garrett Atkins. He’s proven two years in a row that he can hit for a great AVG and drive in runs. His 25 homers is equal to that of Zimmerman. In Zimmerman’s lineup and ballpark (even though they are out of RFK) he will never match the RBI and run totals of Atkins.

  3. Patrick Avatar
    Patrick

    gimme the atkins diet. oooh. that was bad. i admit. lol.

  4. Dreamweapon Avatar
    Dreamweapon

    Brett, please take a look at the optimistic ZiPS line for Zimmerman and tell me that he will “never” match Atkins…..the kid has skills.

    Player Spotlight – Ryan Zimmerman
    Name AVG OBP SLG G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB K SB CS
    Optimistic (15%) .310 .380 .581 162 649 119 201 52 5 38 136 72 103 6 4

    That’s right, 119/38/136. For a 23 yo. That kind of line, at that age, portends a possible future Triple Crown threat. ZiPS isn’t alone, Sheehan at Prospectus says Zimmerman will be “better than David Wright THIS year.” Baseball Analysts list him as the 2nd best 23 yo in the game, behind only Tulowitzki, and ahead of a horde of stellar young players, including Cain, Billingsley, Upton, Kemp, Buchholz, Milledge, etc.

    This isn’t to say I would take Zim ahead of Atkins this year. But it wouldn’t be a slam-dunk for Atkins, and I might well opt for Zim. He’s been consistent, as a very young kid, and now moves to a better park, with a much better lineup. I’m a little worried about the hamate bone injury, but it’s commonplace and reportedly minor in nature, and the fact that he suffered it while taking practice swings on his own at his old high school in NOVEMBER says volumes about the kid’s passion for the game and dedication to self-improvement.

    In a keeper or dynasty, however, I would view this as a slam-dunk. In Zimmerman’s favor.

  5. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Right now, I have Atkins one spot ahead of Zimmerman, but I agree that it’s not a no-brainer here. Zimmerman could swipe 15 bags.

    Atkins this year. Zimmerman in a keeper league.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *