The Scoop

Well, I’m off to Arizona Friday to compete in LABR (NL-only auction held Sunday night). It should be interesting. My strategy might turn out to be fairly radical, but I’ll let you know how it turned out next week. Wish me luck. As for responding to comments (and writing posts, for that matter), it should be pretty sporadic for the next few days, so bear with me. But for now, I’ll leave you with some more thoughts around the league:

Maybe not anymore, but Jeremy Bonderman has to be one of the most overrated players in baseball. Sure, his stuff is very good, but he’s yet to translate that into being an effective pitcher over the course of a year. During five seasons, he’s never had an ERA less than 4.00 or a WHIP less than 1.30. Because he throws so many sliders, he’s also a major injury risk. He’s dominated for stretches, has solid strikeout potential and last year’s soaring ERA can at least partially be explained by an abnormally high BABIP (.329), but he better come at a major discount at this point. His career K:B ratio of 2.56:1 is good, not great.

I really wish Adrian Gonzalez could somehow escape Petco Park. I still like him for fantasy purposes, but a would-be superstar is merely very good because of where he calls home. He still strikes out too much, but if he switched places with Todd Helton, he’d be a first round fantasy pick.

If you prorated Chase Utley’s stats from last year over the course of a full season, here’s what you’d get: 27 HR, 11 SB, 126 RBI, 128 Runs, .332 BA. He’s increased his batting average every season he’s played during his career, has three straight 100-RBI campaigns and is a very effective base stealer (84 percent success rate). He can handle southpaws, and with that lineup and ballpark, he simply can’t fall out of the top-5 of your fantasy draft.

If Joe Torre benches Andy LaRoche in favor of Nomar Garciaparra’s corpse and bats Matt Kemp at the bottom of the order I’m going to flip my lid. I’m convinced there’s a conspiracy why managers consistently go with veterans over younger, better talent. This would never happen in any other profession. Why does it in a billion dollar industry?

This is a good year to target Rafael Furcal, who is both coming off a miserable campaign and entering a contract year. An ankle injury can be partially blamed for his lackluster 2007, but if you compare his 2006 season with Jimmy Rollins’, you’ll find two very similar players. Rollins has improved since then, and I’m certainly not suggesting Furcal will be the better player in 2008, but I am cautioning you not to chase last year’s stats.

Nick Markakis is anything but under the radar these days, but that doesn’t mean he’s still not being undervalued in drafts. Prorate his numbers after the All-Star break last year over the course of a full season, and you get: 31 HR, 20 SB, 135 RBI, 113 Runs, .325 BA. He’s 24 years old. Prediction: Markakis has a better fantasy season than Vladimir Guerrero or Carlos Beltran.


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

7 responses to “The Scoop”

  1. Dreamweapon Avatar
    Dreamweapon

    Bonderman is overrated, but THE most overrated player in pro ball, IMO, is Vernon Wells. Exactly two (2) “good” seasons (not great), years apart. His typical line is basically .275/80/20/80 (and he’s had double-digit steals exactly twice, with blazing totals of 17 and 10….wow). In other words, the same crap you can get ten to fifteen rounds after he’s been taken.

    People want this guy to be the poor man’s Beltran or Sizemore. He’s not even on the same continent. He’s like the upper middle class man’s David DeJesus.

    Torre needs to die if he goes with that lineup. Kemp should hit somewhere 2-5, and Nomar should be fetching Gatorade for the real players.

    Good luck with your draft!

  2. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Great call with V. Wells. I totally agree. So overrated. And I doubt he makes a huge comeback coming off that shoulder too.

    Upper middle class David DeJesus. I like it.

    Thanks.

  3. Donald Trump Avatar
    Donald Trump

    good luck this weekend. Don’t do anything too stupid.
    I like me some bonderman. Always have, always will.

  4. gordonjer Avatar
    gordonjer

    I hate Vernon Wells with a passion. Every year he does badly I’ve been sucked in with his “upside” and taken him. No more I say. NO MORE!!

  5. nate Avatar
    nate

    I would’ve said Bonderman is underrated at this point. Last April he was probably overrated as the next big thing, which he was (best AL starter thru June) until July. Now, everyone seems completely down on the guy, despite the fact that his team has become the team to beat. Don’t get me wrong – I’m not heaping praise here, but he’s got Josh Beckett-like potential for the first half. And if the Tigers offense is generating wins like it should be, it should be easy to trade Bonderman in June/July, even if he’s notorious for the 2nd half plunge/injury.

  6. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    I hear you guys. Bonderman has put together some very good halves of seasons, but good luck trading him at the right time. Maybe he’ll finally put it all together for a full campaign, but I worry about him health-wise. However, I do agree that at this point, he is coming at a discount. He’s post-hype.

  7. Brett Avatar

    Good luck in Arizone… let us know how it turns out.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *