The Scoop

By Dalton Del Don – Senior Writer

Albert Pujols is falling down my draft board. Don’t get me wrong, I’m normally all about drafting guys coming off down years, and Pujols is still unquestionably one of the three best hitters in the game. However, if his lineup protection was concerning, his health woes are flat-out worrisome. I don’t know about you, but I don’t want to spend a top-5 pick on someone who is already talking about surgery in January. Right now, I’d take David Wright, Chase Utley, Ryan Howard and maybe even Miguel Cabrera over him.

Dan Uggla is unlikely to be on any of my fantasy teams this year. The counting stats are nice, but do not underestimate how much of an average-killer the strikeout prone second baseman is. Good luck scoring 113 runs again with a .326 OBP, especially with Miguel Cabrera no longer around. I’d rather a boring option, like Jeff Kent. I wouldn’t even be surprised if Kelly Johnson has a better fantasy season than Uggla.

I’m hardly stepping out on a limb here, but I expect Alex Gordon to be a top-10 fantasy third baseman in 2008. So he failed to live up to big expectations as a 23-year-old – big deal. The talent and swing are still there. Kansas City is actually a very good environment for hitters, and his 25-steal potential is underrated. Gordon is absolutely someone to target.

I’m baffled participating in leagues where Dontrelle Willis is still being drafted in the mid-rounds. Maybe some velocity will return, and maybe the league switch will result in early success thanks to the unique delivery, but really, there’s not a lot to be optimistic about. He’s had poor WHIPs and K:BB ratios for consecutive seasons, including last year, when he allowed a disgusting 29 homers in 177 innings versus righties. A switch to the AL means things might actually be even worse in 2008.

No one’s going to have the same impact Ryan Braun did as a rookie last season, or even Hunter Pence, for that matter, but Evan Longoria might be the closest thing in 2008. If he is given the opportunity, nice numbers should follow.

Felipe Lopez is a solid bounce back candidate. One year removed from a 44-steal campaign, Lopez was a massive disappointment last season, thanks in large part to joining the Nationals. In fact, he was limited to just two homers in 309 at-bats at RFK Stadium. Their new confines should be much more friendly to hitters, and as long as he can beat out Ronnie Belliard, Lopez is an excellent value pick in fantasy leagues.

Here are Scott Kazmir’s numbers after the All-Star break last season: 2.39 ERA, 1.14 WHIP, .222 BAA, 124:31 K:BB ratio over 94.1 innings. A simple change in mechanics combined with maturation led to Kazmir finally reaching his vast potential. His small frame will always bring health questions, and pitching in the AL East is far from ideal, but that type of strikeout ability can only be matched by Erik Bedard. It’d be nice if Kazmir could become more efficient, but after turning just 24 years old this week, there’s still even more room to grow. At worst, consider him a top-10 fantasy pitcher in 2008.

If I’m the Dolphins and I’ve been offered Marion Barber and multiple high round draft picks for the rights to Darren McFadden, my biggest worry would be the cops showing up to arrest me for robbery.

The Tim Lincecum versus Yovani Gallardo debate is not easy. On one hand, Gallardo has better command, poise, an improved Brewers defense behind him and the far superior lineup. On the other hand, Lincecum, although less safe, comes with even more upside. He posted 9.24 K/ 9 IP as a rookie, plays in a pitcher’s paradise and has an elite outfield defense behind him. Obviously, the wins category will be in Gallardo’s favor, but Lincecum’s devastating 95-98 MPH two-seam fastball, curve and developing changeup make him simply one of the toughest pitchers to hit in the game. In the end, both are top-20 fantasy options.

Last year’s numbers hardly suggest it, but Delmon Young could jump into the fantasy elite this season. If he finds himself batting in between Joe Mauer and Justin Morneau, he can remain an average regular and still beat last year’s solid counting stats. Of course, he might also start tapping into that unlimited potential and become a star. A 25/25 season is hardly out of the question, and because his swing produces so many line drives, his average should approach .300 despite less than ideal strikeout totals. Remember that he’s still just 22 years old.

Top-5 Quarterbacks of All-Time

1. Tom Brady
2. Peyton Manning
3. Steve Young
4. Joe Montana
5. Dan Marino


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

16 responses to “The Scoop”

  1. Tyler Durden Avatar
    Tyler Durden

    AMAZING baseball analysis.

    Football: Shame on you.

    Call your piece, Top-5 Quarterbacks of Your-Time

    Top-5 Quarterbacks of All-Time
    1. Otto Graham
    2. Joe Montana
    3. Bart Starr
    4. Johnny Unitas
    5. Dan Marino/Tom Brady/Peyton Manning

  2. Donald Trump Avatar
    Donald Trump

    Apparently, you don’t listen to howard stern on sirius. He had Jerry Rice on this past year. Rice said Montana was the better qb, and that he rarely had to adjust to a montana pass.
    The potential is there, but in a non keeper league, I am avoiding Alex Gordon. I think Arod, Wright, Miggy, Atkins, Upton, Zimmerman, Braun, Aramis, and Chipper are all easily above him. Sure, he might slip into the back half of the top 10, but I don’t see anyone riding to fantasy gold with him.

  3. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Tyler Durden – It’s always tough/impossible to compare eras, but thanks to evolution, athletes keep getting better and better. Otto Graham’s team success is pretty undeniable tho, and the 8.6 YPA is amazing. However, the guy threw more interceptions than touchdowns in the NFL! Football was a completely different game back then. You might as well be comparing apples and automobiles. I mean, even as recently as the 1972 undefeated Dolphins team, the leading WR of that squad had like 29 receptions.

  4. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Donald – Interesting regarding the Rice comment, but for all we know, he said that b/c he likes Montana more on a personal level. You guys are definitely selling Young short. I was closer to putting him No. 2 than I was No. 4. Young’s 8.0 YPA dwarfs Montana’s 7.5, and that’s not even factoring in Young’s rushing ability, which was tremendous. Montana had a 1.96 TD:INT ratio, while Young had a 2.17.

  5. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    I agree with your third base assessment. I’d take any of those guys over Gordon as well. But I’m moving him above the likes of Adrian Beltre, Lowell, Glaus, etc. But like I said, that’s nothing groundbreaking. But his SB ability is underrated.

  6. Tyler Durden Avatar
    Tyler Durden

    “Football was a completely different game back then. You might as well be comparing apples and automobiles.”

    Then, as I said, don’t call your list ‘All-Time’– call it Top 5 QBs of 70’s To Today.

    Regardless of career INT stats, Graham led the Browns to the league championship game in each of his 10 seasons, winning on seven occasions. That is what vaults him to #1 in my book.

    Don’t get me wrong, I love you analysis. I just think your lists — whether sports or movies or music — are often rushed & not as thought out as your columns.

  7. Tyler Durden Avatar
    Tyler Durden

    Otto, 2-Time League MVP

  8. Dreamweapon Avatar
    Dreamweapon

    Argh….one more baseball lineup question (last one for a while, I promise–I know these have to get beyond boring)….

    I get: Erik Bedard, David Ortiz and a prospect to be named later (someone good)

    I give: BJ Upton and the prospect rights to Phil Hughes

    Prospect rights in this league mean you own them, but they are not on your active roster. Once you activate them, you get to keep them for 3 years for free, outside of the normal keeper cap of 7 players. They do NOT retain this status if they are traded following a promotion, but do keep it if dealt prior to promotion by the league owner. So, guys with their prospect status intact and who are already quality major leaguers are worth a ton.

    I’m not worried about Hughes. I have mountains of young arms lined up and he’s probably only my 5th or 6th best. I can pull a guy like Jake McGee as the replacement prospect if I want. So that doesn’t concern me.

    I love Upton, though. I really do. The guy is going to be a Soriano clone, in all likelihood. He’s the best guy in deal by a wide margin.

    That said….the goal is to WIN, and I still haven’t taken a championship in this league (2nd place regular season/4th playoffs is my best). I have speed to replace Upton (Sizemore, Rollins, Weeks, others)….and I don’t have anyone in the DH slot. Ortiz is obviously a machine, and Bedard is WAY, WAY better than the one regular arm I would be looking at keeping (Bonderman).

    Also, the guy offering the deal is a good friend and just inherited the team upon entering the league this year……it’s kind of a mess, I wouldn’t feel bad about helping him out a little, and Upton would be a great block for him. Still, gotta look out for #1….. I don’t know, I just don’t know. I have a number of other power-speed guys, and while I don’t want Ortiz long term, I can always deal him next offseason for other considerations…..

    I know it’s insane, but right now, I’m leaning towards it. My batting would be otherwordly, and a rotation of mostly sub-25 yo pitchers looks a lot better when anchored by an Erik Bedard than Jeremy Bonderman. I think this helps me this year, with me possibly really regretting it long-term. Because I read sites like this, though, I feel like I can afford to make such moves and recover later on…..especially if it helps put me over the top this year. Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated. By all means, if I’m nuts to give up Upton, please, for the love of god, tell me.

  9. Brett Avatar
    Brett

    Thanks for pointing out Uggla’s Ugly numbers.. not worth it.. If you are an Adam Dunn fan, you may still go get Uggla…

    Lopez is an interesting sleeper in the new park for sure…

    I’d take a handful of guys over Pujols, including Matt Holliday…

    Lincecum vs Gallarado? I take the stuff in Lincecum… Gallardo still needs run support to get the wins, which is the one pitching category out of his control.

    If Kazmir were to double his second half stats he’d have about 300 strikeouts this year and a whip of 1.00.. Kazmir and Shields the best 1-2 punch in baseball? Who was 5th last year in whip? James Shields..

    Thoughts on Santana to the Mets? Doesn’t he HAVE to win a minimum of 24 games this year? I think he averaged about 8 starts a year during his time with the Twins where they gave him 0-2 runs in a game and he didn’t get the win.. half of those times getting the loss

  10. Dreamweapon Avatar
    Dreamweapon

    24? That seems like a helluva lot but a 3-4 Win bump should be pretty easy to come by.

    Everyone needs run support. Everyone. No pitcher has ever won a 0-0 game. Lincecum’s support will be amongst the worst of the past 30 years, I kid you not. Cain’s too, which sucks. I feel bad for those kids. The Brewers are going to win 90 games this year. As their best pitcher, Gallardo stands to take a good share of those, so figure on 16-18, with an outside shot at 20. The Giants might not win 60. I cannot see how Lincecum or Cain can possibly top 13-14 wins, max.

    At least none of them will be under any innings restrictions that I know of, so it’ll be a fair race.

  11. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Tyler Durden – I hear you, but football is pretty team oriented. I mean, the greatest QB in the world could never win a Super Bowl and it not be his fault. Maybe Otto was clutch, I don’t know, but unlike say basketball, it’s tough to put team accomplishments too high up the list with football players. But we are in agreement that comparing eras is certainly inexact and not really fair.

  12. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Dreamweapon – Ya Favre belongs in the discussion. No doubt. His durability is pretty remarkable. It’s a tough top-five to crack. No bad choices here.

  13. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Dreamweapon – All things considered, I think I’d do that deal. It sounds like you will still be fine in the SB department, and as much as I love Upton, Ortiz isn’t THAT big of a downgrade for this season alone. Plus, you’ll get Bedard, whom I rank No. 3 as a fantasy starter. He’d be even better in Seattle. It’s tough to recommend anyone to part with Upton, but this deal seems to make sense for you. Bedard is pretty young himself, so this may not even kill you long-term.

  14. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Brett – Ya Holliday over Pujols too. Probably.

    I’m probably not as high on J. Shields as you. I like him, don’t get me wrong I think he’s for real, but he was aided by an easy schedule last year and you better have a truly elite arm pitching in the same division as Bos, NYY and Tor. He’s going to have his work cut out for him not to regress too much this season.

    Santana is probably a top-5 pick in my book now. The switch to the NL is huge. Plus that offense. He could def. approach 22-24 wins if everything breaks right.

  15. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    And everyone quite depressing me with talk about the Giants offense.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *