Monday Morning Quarterback

By Dalton Del Don – Senior Writer

What a wild weekend of football. It’s fitting the year everyone dismisses the Colts is the same one in which they are probably going to win it all. I’ll admit I picked the Ravens to win (although I had Indy covering), but everyone had it completely wrong when they said Indy matched up poorly with Baltimore. How can a team led by Jamal Lewis exploit the Colts’ greatness weakness, the run defense? Also, Baltimore’s biggest strength is the blitz, something that plays perfectly into the hands of Peyton Manning. Entering Saturday, when blitzed, Manning had a 127 QB rating with 12 TDs and zero picks in 119 passes. In 119 blitzes, he was sacked three times. Of course, Manning has a 1/5 TD/INT ratio this postseason, and the team is winning despite not because of him. Go figure.

Andy Reid’s system in Philly is a big reason for the team’s success, but someone please get this guy enrolled in Common Sense 101. His decision to punt on 4th and 15 with 1:48 left on the clock and just two timeouts was indefensible and possibly the worst coaching move I have ever seen. The only downside to a 4th down conversion failure was losing 20-30 yards of field position (it’s doubtful N.O. attempts a 50-yard FG to increase the lead from 3-6 points), and either way, a Saints’ first down ends it. By the way, Philly had given up 208 rushing yards. I don’t get why the media is half-heartedly questioning this reasoning – it’s almost a fireable offense.

Something’s not quite right with the Bears’ defense right now.

Score another one for Bill Belichick – Deion Branch isn’t worth the money.

Tom Brady has been known to lock onto a WR come playoff time (i.e. Branch), but I apologize to you, Jabar Gaffney. I predicted Caldwell, foolishly omitting Gafney from my top-30 WR fantasy playoff list. Gaffney had 11 regular season catches; in two playoff games, he has 18 catches for 207 yards and a score.

It’s not by chance the Patriots seem to find a way to win and San Diego finds a way to lose come playoff time. The Chargers, filled with more talent on both sides of the ball, simply gave that game away Sunday. I know it’s way too much to ask, but why would McCree intercept that ball on fourth down when it was going to lose his team yardage, not to mention the possibility of fumbling it? Think SD could’ve used an extra timeout instead of unsuccessfully challenging a clear call on the field? Worse yet, in the season-defining drive with 4:00 minutes left, Schottenheimer calls on Eric Parker on back-to-back plays? Meanwhile, LaDainian Tomlinson and his ho-hum 7.5 yards per touch is ignored. There’s a reason Schottenheimer is 5-13 during the postseason, and it’s not called luck.

And what about LT going off after the game, and then calling Belichick out in the media? This postseason has been filled with great games, and bottom line, the two best teams in each conference are left standing.


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

4 responses to “Monday Morning Quarterback”

  1. Nat Avatar
    Nat

    You forgot: “Why would Schottenheimer go for it on 4th and 11 (!) in the 1st quarter when he has a pro-bowl kicker in Kaeding warming up to kick?”

  2. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Exactly. Good call, that one was definitely worth mentioning. The best part about that decision was when Belichick elected to try an even longer FG with a rookie kicker on the very next drive.

    Schottenheimer must’ve been worried about that being too conservative criticism.

  3. Keith Avatar
    Keith

    Seeing some of the stuff that happens in football games, like those mentioned above…and while not nearly as egregious, I would also have thrown another pass before Kaeding’s final kick (and I would have made sure Rivers didn’t throw that previous 3 yard pass to Gates that cost 20 seconds…though I’ll acknowledge a coach can’t truly “control” the players), anyway, as bad as coaches can be on the biggest of stages, I’m convinced that with about 5 years of working my way up I could at least be an average coach. Too many coaches get credit because of past successes (which were usually due to superior talent) and reputation. I don’t want to steal from Bill Simmons, but older coaches seem to really be losing it. They believe in the “running wins in the playoffs” no matter what, even after having seen Martz win with Kurt Warner and near complete abandonment of the run game. We’ve seen younger “new age” GM’s and such grab prominent positions in baseball, but aside from some coordinators in football (and Belichick), football still seems very old school, and I just don’t get it.

  4. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Like McCree, Gates should have just knocked that pass down (and Rivers should have never thrown it). Normally I’m all about calling plays no-huddle in those late game situations, but a spike was also warranted there too.

    I agree with that old coaching theory. Do you realize Bill Parcells hasn’t won a playoff game in 11 years? Football def. needs to take a cue from baseball and get some more innovative thinkers in there.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *