Coaching Strategies

By Robby Wellington – Staff Writer

I’m not a big fan of many bets this week. I’m probably going to tease the Colts (-9) at home in a bounce back special against a devastated Eagles squad with the Vikings (-6) at home against the awful Cardinals. Wish me luck.

Now, a few things I wanted to touch on. The only time I can remember a team letting another team score a touchdown was in Super Bowl XXXII. Despite the criticism that Mike Holmgren endured, the so-called “concession touchdown” is completely underutilized in football. To wit, last Sunday night, the Denver Broncos tackled LaDainian Tomlinson not once, but twice, when they should have allowed a “concession touchdown.” Instead of getting the ball back with nearly three minutes down eight, the Broncos had to drive the length of the field with no timeouts and 1:10 on the clock. (4th Quarter play-by-play) Even if they had held the Chargers to a field goal, the Broncos would have had less than 30 seconds to get downfield and line up for a field goal with no timeouts. At least one coach recognized this scenario, as Marty Schottenheimer called for Drew Brees to take a knee on second and goal. Well played.

Other things that I would like to see coaches or players do more:

1. A running back intentionally drop a pass that is thrown to them well into the backfield and has “five-yard-loss” written all over it. Or, a running back throw a ball out of bounds when they are bottled up on a run for a big loss. In fact, I have always been a big fan of the throwing running back. My one major gripe is that it has always seemed to be an all-or-nothing endeavor. If the running back is supposed to throw it, well, he’s going to throw it, regardless of downfield coverage. How about a fake pass every once in a while and then a 5-10 yard scramble. I could see Michael Vick doing this a lot next year with Matt Schaub under center. Watch out!

2. I would also like to see a team down by a wide margin (three to four touchdowns) actually go for it early in the forth quarter instead of punting and basically conceding defeat. You would rather keep the score respectable than have a shot, however so slight, at actually winning the game? Really?

3. Lastly, and this is my personal favorite, I would love to see a team down two touchdowns late in a game (less than four minutes left) score a touchdown and go for two to try and cut the lead to six. Now, hear me out on this one. If, for example, the Falcons had scored late last week to cut the Ravens lead to a touchdown, they would have needed to get the ball back and score another touchdown to tie and send the game to overtime. Well, why not go for two after that first touchdown? If they convert it, then a touchdown wins and if they don’t, then they still have a chance to score, go for two again and send the game to overtime. Simply put, if the chances of converting for two once outweighs the chances of not converting for two twice (which it virtually always does) then teams would be best suited to go for it.

NFL 2-point conversion rates hover around 43%. Using this figure, the chances a team will be unsuccessful on conversions twice in a row is calculated as 32.48% (.57 * .57). So, using this strategy, a team would have a 43% chance at winning, a 32.5% chance at losing, and a 24.5% chance at sending the game to overtime, as opposed to a 100% chance of sending the game to overtime. Also, this assumes that an extra point is a given, while the actual conversion rate is 94%, which only helps to bolster my argument.


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

7 responses to “Coaching Strategies”

  1. Marty Schottenheimer Avatar
    Marty Schottenheimer

    Just because we didn’t comment, doesn’t mean we don’t love you and all the hard work you do, Robby.

  2. Dusty Avatar
    Dusty

    Hey Robby this is the best article ever!

  3. Robby Avatar
    Robby

    Thanks guys!

  4. Mike Holmgren Avatar
    Mike Holmgren

    Hey Robby, you are the second coming of Jesus Christ.

  5. Keith Avatar
    Keith

    You’re a brilliant, brilliant man, Robby.

    I’d also like to add that there’s just a general lack of cajones among NFL coaches. Some of it is in regards to bucking convention like some of these moves above, but a lot of it just seems to be more of a fear of failure and being second-guessed. There are so many chances on 4th downs for teams to really put their opponents away, and coaches just don’t go for the jugular, and opt to play it safe. I’m not advocating Mike Martz give coaching “how to” classes, but teams that leave the door open seem to end up with it slammed in their faces. The 49ers game this past weekend was a prime example. Mike Nolan has irked me to no end for being too conservative (I would have kicked the 52-yard field goal as well, rather than punting). But with 4 minutes left, 4th down and maybe an inch to go…if a field goal puts you up two scores, I’m with you, kick it. But really, what team can’t pick up an inch on a QB sneak. I wouldn’t advocate handing off at all, so maybe if it’s a couple feet to go, I’d kick the FG, but it was ONE INCH! Even if you convert and still get a FG, just by running the ball 3-4 more times, you’re going to take enough time off the clock to make a comeback impossible. Heck, even if you get stopped (by some absolute miracle), they are pinned very deep in their own territory…yeah, they would only need a field goal, but with the way teams have been pressuring Bulger, a safety is a very real possibility. Bottom line, I think it was a weak call, and typical of most insecure coaches these days.

    Since I do agree with your list Robby, let me add one of mine. QB’s calling time outs on 1st and 10’s with the play clock winding down…especially late in halves of close games. If it’s 3rd and 1, I understand, but having time outs at the end of halves or games can be an absolutely huge difference maker. HUGE. Teams treat 5 yards on 1st or 2nd down like they’re absolutely critical. While by no means insignificant, facing an occassional 1st and 15 I would think is much preferable rather than having to drive the field at the end of a game with one less time out.

  6. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    The 49ers definitely blew it yesterday. Especially since A. Smith is a pretty good runner, it seems especially likely he could get the inch. Similarly, Gore needs to be able to stay on the field b/c M. Robinson isn’t getting it done in short yardage situations.

  7. Keith Avatar
    Keith

    Robinson’s run on 3rd down is a whole seperate issue…if he just angles off to the left a little bit, or actually just makes a quick cut towards the outside, the whole thing is a non-issue. I think Gore would have been in there if he wasn’t hurt, and I have a hard time getting mad at a rookie converted QB who runs hard all the time (though not intelligently)…but it was really the call that irked me the most. Heck, to gain 1″, you don’t have to be a good running QB, or a good anything for that matter…it’s just a quick snap and lunge. It’s a little tougher since it’s loud on the road, but I think in this league, you have to go for the kill…and if you don’t think you can get 1″ at a critical point in a game, you probably don’t belong.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *