RotoScoop.com

Don’t Give Up, Don’t Ever Give Up

By Robby Wellington – Staff Writer

Rich Harden and Gary Sheffield were probably taken in the top three rounds of most leagues this year. Now their value is next to nothing. Or so most people would think. Depending on a number of factors, these two are still reasonably valuable fantasy commodities that should not be given up on.

Rich

Coming into this year, Harden was considered an injury risk by many, even though none of his injuries were actually attributable to the rigors of pitching. As such, he was an under-the-radar stud who many “smart” owners targeted in the early rounds. Well, after back and elbow injuries this year, you can pencil Harden in right below a couple Cub ex-aces in the brittleness rankings. Although reports from A’s camp are saying that Harden may only be out 6-8 weeks, the smart money is on him being out for the remainder of the year. That being said, Harden should not be dropped in all but the shallowest of leagues. In rotisserie leagues, if you can spare the DL spot, stash him away and hope for the best. If not, try and shop him to an owner who can. As a rule of thumb, I try not to drop a player who someone will be anxious to snag off waivers. Harden still carries some value to any team with a vacant DL spot. In head-to-head leagues, Harden is significantly more valuable. If you are at the top of your league and a lock for the playoffs, then you can probably afford the deadweight on your team, even if it means dropping a seed come postseason time. If you’re struggling and trying to claw your way into the top half of the league, try and move Harden to someone who can spare the spot.

Gary

The Sheffield situation is very similar to Harden’s, and, as such, you should treat him in a similar fashion. However, while Harden could be back anywhere from six weeks to never, Sheffield should be back in September, although the time off and weak wrist might limit his effectiveness. Remember though, the Yankees have a very favorable September schedule, and if you are in a head-to-head league and can afford it, I strongly encourage you to acquire and stash Sheff.

Posted

in

by

RotoScoop

Tags:

Comments

6 responses to “Don’t Give Up, Don’t Ever Give Up”

  1. James Avatar
    James

    At least Sheff is taking care of the problem, I knew surgery was going to end up being the only option. How quickly his power stroke returns is the major question. But I guess I’ll have to hold onto him like you said.

  2. Robert Avatar
    Robert

    Yep, Harden is officially full blown injury prone. He’ll be lucky to return by September.

  3. Andrew Avatar
    Andrew

    So I should trade Uggla for Sheff and Francis?

  4. RotoScoop Avatar
    RotoScoop

    Uggla has been playing better than expected, but I wouldn’t count on it contuing at a similar pace. Especially if you are in a head-to-head league I say make the deal and Sheff will be there for the most important time. Francis has been real solid himself. If you have a decent MI to replace Uggla, then I say go for it.

  5. Dustin Avatar
    Dustin

    You are crazy. Wasting DL spots on both of these guys is crazy, especially Sheffield. Once it is realized the Yankees are out of contention for the playoffs, Sheffield will be put on the shelf… come on! stop giving these people horrid advice.

  6. Robby Avatar
    Robby

    Dustin, your last name isn’t Rever-Ginsburg is it? I certainy hope not. As I stated, if you have an extra DL spot, then you might as well hang on to Harden and Sheffield. Its not like you are using the spot for anything else so you’re not “wasting” it, are you? If you don’t have an extra DL spot then try and shop them to someone who does and try and get anything in return (as opposed to just dropping them).
    Also, in head-to-head leagues where your team already has a playoff spot more or less locked in, these guys still have decent value. The bottom line is that there are teams in all leagues who should have these guys on their rosters. So, ummm, Dustin, why don’t you eat my dick or something. Cheers.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *